Hibiscus Teach · Comedy · Lesson 7
South Park 7: Requests, Rules and Real Needs
Requests, Rules and Real Needs
State a preference, ask about a rule respectfully and discuss an exception while respecting privacy.
Created by Denis M., British English teacher.
Content note: Adult comedy, an argument about food and a classroom request to use the restroom. Keep discussion of personal needs fictional and respect privacy.
Watch once for the situation. Replay one useful moment, complete the six questions, then use the new English in conversation. Answer about the selected section only. Questions marked Apply use original practice examples.
How to use this lesson
Watch each clip, then try its activities.
A menu that misses the request
Randy makes elaborate food for his family and a school cafeteria. Stan asks for the pizza that was promised on the lunch schedule.
Watch for: Does renaming the food answer what the listener actually wants?
Clip A quiz · 6 questions
Answer about this clip only. Choose one answer for each question.
1–2 minGrammar in a minuteC1 · A pseudo-cleft focusing the offered dish
“what I have for you is a nice goat cheese and heirloom tomato frittata”
Clip 1, quotation excerpt
What I have for you forms the subject; the following dish name provides the focus. A new it-cleft can shift this into It is … that I have for you while retaining the offered item.
Useful English
Original practice phrases.
The schedule says… Could we have that option?
Refer to a clear expectation.
I appreciate the effort, but this is not the option I asked for.
Acknowledge work while clarifying a preference.
Keep talking · 3 questions
Say your answer aloud before opening the support. With a partner, take turns and ask a follow-up question.
Why might an impressive alternative still disappoint someone?
Support and one possible answer
It may… while…
It may show effort while failing to meet the stated preference or expectation.
How can Stan express the same preference more calmly?
Support and one possible answer
Acknowledge… and ask…
Acknowledge the work and ask for the option listed on the schedule.
Respond to a fictional service change.
Support and one possible answer
State the expectation, acknowledge the effort and ask for an alternative.
Thank you for preparing this. The schedule said we would have a simple option. Is that still available, or could we agree another choice?
A rule and an urgent exception
One student is allowed to leave class. Another questions the fairness of the rule and says he urgently needs the restroom.
Watch for: How can somebody ask about an inconsistent rule without demanding private details?
Clip B quiz · 6 questions
Answer about this clip only. Choose one answer for each question.
1–2 minGrammar in a minuteB2 · Reporting infrequent permission in a passive
“you rarely let us get up and leave during a class”
Clip 2, quotation excerpt
Rarely applies to let, making the permission infrequent. Passive be allowed to reports that permission; retain rarely rather than replacing it with never.
Useful English
Original practice phrases.
Could you explain how the rule applies in this case?
Ask about consistency respectfully.
I have an urgent need. Could I speak to you privately?
Request help without announcing private details.
Keep talking · 3 questions
Say your answer aloud before opening the support. With a partner, take turns and ask a follow-up question.
Does fairness always require an identical response?
Support and one possible answer
Fairness may require…
Fairness may require a consistent process that also considers relevant circumstances. The class does not need private details about every exception.
What connects the menu disagreement with the classroom rule?
Support and one possible answer
Both involve…
Both involve an expectation that does not match someone's actual need. A clear request can identify the difference.
Ask for an exception in a fictional group activity.
Support and one possible answer
State the general expectation, request privacy and agree a practical next step.
I know we normally stay until the end, but I have an urgent need to leave early. Could I speak to you privately and agree how to catch up?
1–2 minGrammar masteryB2 · A reported request for permission
“i just need to go to the restroom”
Clip 2, quotation excerpt
Report a permission request with ask + person + if/whether + statement order. Could gives the past-time modal viewpoint.
