The Holdovers · There’s More to the Story

← More film and television lessons

Hibiscus Teach · Movies

The Holdovers

There's More to the Story

Revise an impression using new information, distinguish an account from an established fact and discuss privacy without excusing dishonesty automatically.

B2+/C1 English60-minute tutor lesson

Created by , British English teacher.

The holiday rules

In this story, the selected scene focuses on the holiday rules.

Watch for: How does he frame the restrictions, and how do the pupils respond?

Original source

Selected exchanges from the same holiday briefing, in story order.

Clip A quiz · 6 questions

Answer about this clip only. Choose one answer for each question.

1. What does Hunham acknowledge at the start?
2. What schedule does he say they will follow?
3. What academic requirement remains?
4. How is recreation described?
5. What objection does Angus raise about outdoor exercise?
6. Why must they sleep in the infirmary?

Useful English

Could you explain which restriction is necessary and which is a preference?

I understand the practical problem, but the arrangement still needs discussion.

Keep talking · 3 questions

Say your answer before opening the support. Take turns with a partner, or speak aloud on your own.

  1. How does Hunham try to justify the schedule?

    Support and one possible answer

    He appeals to…

    He appeals to institutional rules, discipline and the supposed benefits of adversity.

  2. Which objections concern practical needs rather than simply dislike?

    Support and one possible answer

    One practical issue is…

    One practical issue is that the gym is not available while outdoor conditions are uncomfortable.

  3. Challenge a rule without rejecting all structure.

    Support and one possible answer

    I accept… but could…?

    I accept that we need shared meal times, but could the study period allow some choice?

Hunham tells Angus about Harvard

In this story, the selected scene focuses on hunham tells angus about harvard.

Watch for: What does Hunham say happened, and how does he distinguish the accusation from the reason for his expulsion?

Original source

Clip B quiz · 6 questions

Answer about this clip only. Choose one answer for each question.

1. What accusation does Hunham say his roommate made?
2. How does Hunham respond to that accusation in his account?
3. What does he then say actually caused his expulsion?
4. What advantage does Hunham say his roommate's family had?
5. What injury does Hunham say his roommate suffered?
6. How does Hunham describe the car incident?

Useful English

I had made an assumption without knowing the whole story.

Understanding an explanation does not mean accepting every justification.

Keep talking · 3 questions

Say your answer before opening the support. Take turns with a partner, or speak aloud on your own.

  1. Which claims are Hunham's account rather than independently confirmed facts?

    Support and one possible answer

    He says…; the clip itself…

    He says the roommate stole from him and the incident was accidental; the conversation presents his account rather than independent proof.

  2. Can sympathy coexist with criticism of an action?

    Support and one possible answer

    We can understand… without…

    We can understand someone's fear of humiliation without treating every response to it as justified.

  3. Revise an impression carefully.

    Support and one possible answer

    I previously thought…; now I understand…

    I previously thought the decision was simple. Now I understand there were pressures I had not considered, although I still have questions.

Mastery: use your English

Apply language from both clips to new situations.

Mastery · 6 questions

Use the English in new situations. Choose one answer for each question.

1. Separate an account from a proven conclusion.
2. Revise a view without swinging to another certainty.
3. Challenge a justification.
4. Ask about a restriction.
5. Respond to a confidence.
6. Summarise a nuanced view.

Put it all together — speaking

Use English from both clips. For the last conversation, take a role each. On your own, practise both roles.

  1. How does the second clip complicate the authority shown in the first?

    Support and one possible answer

    The first presents…; the second reveals…

    The first presents a strict authority figure; the second reveals an account of vulnerability, choices and dependence on another person's support.

  2. Where is the line between keeping privacy and creating a false impression?

    Support and one possible answer

    Privacy may involve…; deception may…

    Privacy may involve declining to share a detail; deception may involve giving a false account. Context matters, but the distinction should not disappear.

  1. Can you revisit a tense working relationship without pretending everything is resolved?

    Role A

    You thought a colleague was being uncooperative about a deadline. You now learn they had a competing responsibility. Acknowledge the assumption without demanding private details.

    Role B

    Explain the practical conflict while keeping personal information private. Accept one communication improvement and negotiate a clearer arrangement.

    Support

    State an earlier assumption, hear new information, acknowledge a concern and agree one practical change.

    Check your conversation

    • Complete the communication goal on both role cards.
    • Use language from both clips naturally, with at least three target items overall.
    • Ask a relevant question and respond to your partner, rather than delivering two unrelated speeches.
    • Finish with a clear decision, next step or summary; repeat one part after feedback.
    One possible conversation, after your attempt

    A: I assumed you were ignoring the deadline. I should have checked. B: I had another responsibility, but I could have warned you sooner. I would prefer not to share the personal details. A: That is fine. Could we agree a way to flag a conflict early? B: Yes. I can send a brief message with an alternative time.

    I assumed you were refusing to help. I now understand that the deadline conflicted with another responsibility. Could we agree how to flag conflicts earlier?

    Try again: After feedback, repeat the most difficult exchange. Improve one language point and one communication point; do not memorise the example.

Original teaching activities: Hibiscus Teach. Film and television clips belong to their respective owners.