Hibiscus Teach · Vids · The Good Place

Ideas, Actions and Responsibility

Explain a principle, question its reasons respectfully and compare the consequences of a difficult choice.

B2–B2+ · Adults60 minutes

Created by Denis M., British English teacher.

Related lessons

C1Present Tenses for Storytelling, Summaries and Attitude
B2The Office 2

Content note: Adult drama: death, ethical dilemmas and comic but bloody trolley violence. Personal ethical positions are not graded.

Warm-up: Can a well-intended decision still cause a problem? Give a harmless invented example.

Learn the words, watch, then check your understanding. Practise the phrases and brief speaking tasks. Finish with the mastery quiz and final conversation.

Vocabulary helps you discuss the scenes; not every entry is spoken in the clips.

Practice voice: American English.

Practice MP3 update deferred

Listening before challenging

Chidi explains a view of character and actions. Eleanor appears distracted, then challenges why they should listen to a philosopher.

Watch for: Is Eleanor engaging with the idea or just questioning the authority behind it?

New vocabulary

Read the words and examples before you watch.

voluntary: done by choice rather than being forced
Joining the study group is voluntary.
character: the qualities that describe how a person tends to behave
A difficult choice can reveal something about character.
authority: a person treated as having knowledge or the right to decide
We can question an authority's reasoning respectfully.
challenge: question an idea or claim because it may need justification
Challenge the assumption by asking for evidence.

Original on YouTube ↗

Watch and check · 6 questions

Answer about this clip only. Choose one answer for each question.

1. Whose student does Chidi say Aristotle was?Plato's.Michael's.Eleanor's.

2. What does the view Chidi describes connect character with?A person's favourite clothes.A person's actions.A person's travel tickets.

3. What does Chidi accuse Eleanor of choosing to do?Leave the city.Cook a meal.Ignore the person teaching her.

4. What does Eleanor question?Why they should listen to these thinkers.Whether they have enough food.How to book a flight.

5. Apply: which question engages with the reasoning?Your name proves every idea is wrong.What reasons support that conclusion?Nobody should ever question a philosopher.

6. Apply: which sentence connects a principle with a real decision?The principle removes every possible dilemma.We can ignore the details because we know the name.I understand the general view; what would it imply for this choice?

1–2 minGrammar in a minuteC1 · Present tense summarising an intellectual position

“Aristotle believes that your character is voluntary because it's just the result of your actions”

Clip 1, quotation excerpt

The present believes can summarise a thinker’s position in an academic discussion. The that-clause gives the attributed claim; because introduces its stated justification, rather than dating the belief.

Which account preserves the present summary and the relationship between the two subordinate clauses?Because makes the actions the time when the belief stopped, while that introduces a separate command.The speaker presents a philosophical position and its justification as ideas under discussion, rather than locating a new act of belief today.The present tense necessarily reports that Aristotle has newly adopted the belief today.

Grammar support

C1Present Tenses for Storytelling, Summaries and Attitude

Useful English

Original practice phrases.

Could you explain the reason behind that view?

Ask about an argument rather than dismissing a person.

I understand the principle. How would it apply here?

Connect an abstract idea with a specific situation.

Keep talking · 3 questions

Say your answer aloud before opening the support. With a partner, take turns and ask a follow-up question.

What connects an ethics lesson with the trolley experiment?
Support and one possible answer
Both ask… but…
Both ask about actions and responsibility. The trolley scene adds pressure by making a theoretical choice feel immediate.
Is questioning an authority enough to challenge an argument?
Support and one possible answer
It can start… but…
It can start a discussion, but we also need to examine the reasons and how the idea applies.
Discuss a fictional dilemma without dismissing your partner.
Support and one possible answer
Explain a principle, ask for the other view, compare consequences and agree a next step.
I think we should keep the original agreement. What concern do you see? Let us compare who would be affected before deciding.

When theory becomes immediate

Chidi discusses a moral thought experiment, and Michael makes the situation unexpectedly immediate.

First watch: How does the change in setting affect Chidi’s response?

New vocabulary

a dilemma: A difficult choice between competing possibilities.The promise created a dilemma when a second person needed help.
an outcome: The result of an action or process.A good intention does not guarantee a good outcome.
in principle: In theory or as a general position.I agree in principle, but the details still matter.
be put on the spot: Be required to respond before you feel ready.She was put on the spot when everyone asked for an immediate answer.

Original on YouTube ↗

Watch and check · 6 questions

All six questions refer to this clip. Choose one answer per question.

Listen for the evidence1. What does Michael initially ask Chidi to give him?A. The right answer to the problem.B. A map of the neighbourhood.C. Permission to leave the lesson.

Listen for the evidence2. Why does Chidi resist giving Michael one definite answer?A. He has forgotten the question.B. He says the problem has no single right answer.C. He wants to keep the answer secret until tomorrow.

Listen for the evidence3. What contrast creates the basic dilemma?A. Choosing between two equally populated routes.B. Saving a friend or several strangers.C. Harm to five people on one route or one on another.

Use picture and dialogue4. What does Michael do to the classroom exercise?A. Turns it into a realistic experience for Chidi.B. He lets the class vote on a single written answer.C. He asks Chidi to defend the answer in a debate.

Use picture and dialogue5. What position does Chidi occupy in the simulation?A. He only explains the rules to someone else who must decide.B. He is required to make the trolley decision.C. He observes the result after another character has already acted.

Interpret the scene6. Which contrast is supported by Chidi’s reaction?A. Michael’s involvement removes all emotional consequences for Chidi.B. Having taught the theory makes the practical decision effortless.C. Explaining a choice calmly is different from facing it under pressure.

Answer key and explanations

A. The right answer to the problem. Correct. Michael asks for the right answer before Chidi explains the nature of the dilemma.
B. He says the problem has no single right answer. Correct. Chidi presents the absence of one right answer as a central feature of the trolley problem.
C. Harm to five people on one route or one on another. Correct. The numbers create a conflict between the routes.
A. Turns it into a realistic experience for Chidi. Correct. He changes the distance between discussing and facing the situation.
B. He is required to make the trolley decision. Correct. He is no longer only explaining it to others.
C. Explaining a choice calmly is different from facing it under pressure. Correct. His reaction illustrates that gap.

1–2 minGrammar in a minuteC1 · A fixed participial comment setting a viewpoint

“ethically speaking”

Clip 2, quotation excerpt

Ethically speaking is a fixed viewpoint comment: from an ethical perspective. It differs from an ordinary action participle whose implied actor must be the main clause’s subject.

Which analysis explains why this opening can comment on an evaluation without claiming that its subject literally speaks?It sets the domain of evaluation and functions as a comment, rather than narrating an act of speaking by the thing evaluated.It means the thing evaluated is speaking ethically, so every following subject must be a human speaker.It reports that an ethical speech was completed before the evaluation and therefore requires having spoken.

Grammar support

C1–C2Participle Clauses

Useful phrases

Original language for practice, not programme quotations.

I agree in principle, but I would want to know more.
Express provisional agreement while identifying uncertainty.

My concern is what happens to the other people involved.
Bring consequences for others into the discussion.

Speaking · 3 brief prompts

Answer aloud for 20–45 seconds. Add a reason or example. With a tutor, ask one follow-up question.

What changes when Chidi is placed inside the problem?
One possible answer
He faces urgency and disturbing consequences instead of discussing an abstract choice.
Does hesitation always mean someone has no principles?
One possible answer
No. A person may hesitate because two important principles conflict.
Make one objection without attacking the other person.
One possible answer
I understand your aim, but I am concerned about the person left without support.

Mastery: use what you have learnt

Use language from both clips in new situations.

Mastery · 6 questions

Use language from both clips in a new situation.

1. Character concerns…qualities shown in how a person behavesa travel schedulea film ticket price

2. Which challenge asks about reasoning?A name proves a claim.What reasons support that conclusion?I refuse to listen to the idea.

3. In principle means…without any possible exception in practiceonly after every detail is settledas a general position or in theory

4. Which reply recognises a dilemma?Both options affect people; let us compare the consequences.Only my intention matters.The louder person is automatically right.

5. Which question connects an idea with an action?Who has the grandest title?How would that principle apply to this decision?Can we ignore the actual choice?

6. Which reply allows a considered answer under pressure?Answer instantly or you are wrong.There is no need to examine the options.I need a moment to weigh up the likely outcomes.

Put it together

Final speaking · 12 minutes

Discuss a fictional dilemma without dismissing your partner.

Role A

You think a group should keep its original agreement. Explain your principle and consider the likely effects.

Role B

Raise a different concern, ask for the reasons behind the principle and agree how to evaluate both options.

Practise

Prepare your position with a clear reason.
Take turns, ask a specific question and respond to the answer.
Agree a next step, then swap roles and retry.

On your own: practise both roles aloud.

Success criteria

Use target language from both clips.
Ask a clear question and respond to the answer.
End with a specific next step, while acknowledging any uncertainty.

One possible conversation

I think we should keep the original agreement. What concern do you see? Let us compare who would be affected before deciding.

1–2 minGrammar masteryC1 · A perfect participle and a later outcome

“so we could see how the ethics would actually play out.”

From this lesson’s clip, quotation excerpt

Having set up marks an earlier active action by the main subject. Would play out keeps the outcome later than that past setup.

New practice: add our earlier setup. Which version keeps the setup active, its subject correct and the outcome prospective from then?Having set up the experiment, we could see how the ethics had already played out.Having set up the experiment, we could see how the ethics would actually play out.Having been set up, we could see how the ethics would actually play out.

Grammar support

C1–C2Participle Clauses

More practice

Try another lesson with film or television clips.

B2The Office
B2The Good Fight

Finish by choosing two useful expressions and saying how you could use them.

Return to Vids