Learn English with Billions

More film and television lessons

Hibiscus Teach · Series

Billions

Confidence Is Not the Same as Evidence

Question an explanation, distinguish delivery from support, and propose a fair participation method.

B2–C1 English target60-minute lesson target

Adults: public shaming, strong language and fictional claims about wealth and power. Discuss rhetoric and participation, not legal or investment advice.

Created by , British English teacher.

S5E4: We're Here to Learn Together, Not Be Shamed

Chuck starts teaching a law class, but his response to an unprepared student meets resistance.

Watch for: How is participation encouraged: or discouraged?

Original source

Clip A quiz: 6 questions

Answer about this clip. Replay when you need to. Choose one answer for each question.

1. What is Chuck trying to establish?
2. What has the student not prepared?
3. How does Chuck respond to passing on a question?
4. What objection is raised?
5. What alternative does the visitor suggest?
6. What happens when participation is invited?

1–2 minGrammar in a minuteC1 · Recovering a verb after can
“the highest level a lawyer can”

Clip 1, quotation excerpt

Can allows an omitted verb phrase. In this relative clause, recover rise to from rose to the highest level. The highest level supplies the understood object of to.

Which expansion correctly recovers both the omitted verb and the relative clause’s missing object?

Useful English

I understand the expectation, but could we try another approach?

You say: Challenge the format without rejecting preparation.

One possible response

I understand the expectation, but could we discuss in pairs first?

Could someone volunteer an example?

You say: Invite a volunteer to explain the first step.

One possible response

Could someone volunteer to explain the first step?

Keep talking: 3 questions

Speak before opening the help or example. With a partner, ask a follow-up. On your own, say your answer aloud.

  1. Which moment changes the atmosphere?

    Help me start

    The atmosphere changes when…

    Show an example

    The invitation gives students a different reason to speak.

  2. What helps you answer a difficult question?

    Help me start

    I need…

    Show an example

    I need a moment to organise my thoughts, not an immediate rescue.

  3. Ask for a more helpful way to participate.

    Help me start

    Acknowledge the goal; suggest a method.

    Show an example

    I know preparation matters. Could I first explain the part I understood?

S5E3: I Selected Myself

Axe addresses his son’s school after a disciplinary dispute and presents his own account of success.

Watch for: How does he frame breaking the school’s expectations?

Original source

Clip B quiz: 6 questions

Answer about this clip. Replay when you need to. Choose one answer for each question.

1. Who is Axe addressing?
2. How does he frame his son’s conduct?
3. What does he challenge?
4. How does he describe his own advancement?
5. What does his speech praise?
6. What response is shown from the audience?

1–2 minGrammar in a minuteC1 · As-inversion with a changed time reference
“As will you, soon enough.”

Clip 2, quotation excerpt

As + auxiliary + subject echoes the preceding predicate. Here will predicts that the listeners will also love the result; it changes the time viewpoint while recovering love the result.

Which expansion preserves the recovered predicate and the future viewpoint?

Useful English

What evidence supports that claim?

You say: Ask what supports a claim about the project’s results.

One possible response

What evidence supports that claim about the results?

Does that example justify an exception?

You say: Ask whether one success justifies changing the rule.

One possible response

Does one success justify changing the rule?

Keep talking: 3 questions

Speak before opening the help or example. With a partner, ask a follow-up. On your own, say your answer aloud.

  1. Which claim would you ask him to explain?

    Help me start

    I would ask about…

    Show an example

    I would ask how one example supports his wider conclusion.

  2. Can a confident delivery hide a weak explanation?

    Help me start

    It can when…

    Show an example

    It can when listeners remember the style but not the evidence.

  3. Question a rule-breaking justification without attacking the speaker.

    Help me start

    Name the claim; ask for support.

    Show an example

    You say the outcome justified the exception. What evidence connects the two?

Mastery: use your English

Apply language and ideas from both clips in new situations.

Mastery: 6 questions

Use the English in a new situation. Choose one answer for each question.

1. A trainer says public questioning is essential. Ask for evidence without rejecting the goal.
2. Invite participation without choosing someone unexpectedly.
3. One person succeeded after ignoring a rule. Ask about generalising.
4. A confident speaker makes an unsupported claim. Respond to the claim rather than the style.
5. Acknowledge preparation while requesting thinking time.
6. Summarise two different proposals without declaring a winner.

Put it all together: speaking

Use English from both clips. Start with the two short questions, then take a private role each. On your own, practise both roles.

  1. How do the two clips use authority differently?

    Help me start

    In the first…; in the second…

    Show an example

    One concerns how a class participates; the other challenges a school’s judgment through a confident speech.

  2. What would make a discussion both demanding and fair?

    Help me start

    Preparation plus…

    Show an example

    Preparation can be expected while students receive time and different ways to contribute.

  3. Can you reach a workable outcome together using the two private role cards?

    Private Role A

    You run a workshop and need every participant to prepare. You have only 20 minutes and cannot abandon the learning goal. Ask what makes the current questioning difficult.

    Private Role B

    You prepared but need 30 seconds to formulate an answer. You can offer a written example first, a possibility the trainer does not know. Negotiate a participation method.

    Open only your own role card. Share its information by speaking, without showing the card.

    Help me start

    Discover the missing information; explain your constraint; respond to your partner; agree on a practical next step. Use language from both clips.

    Check your conversation

    • Complete the practical goal on both role cards.
    • Use at least three target items naturally, including language from each clip.
    • Ask a relevant follow-up and respond to information you did not know.
    • End with a clear agreement, next step or summary.
    Show an example

    A: Preparation matters, but I see that immediate answers are difficult. B: I can show a written example first. A: Could that be followed by one short question? B: Yes, with a moment to think. A: Let us try that and review it afterwards.

    Try again: The workshop must now be five minutes shorter. Keep the preparation requirement and agree how everyone can still contribute.

1–2 minGrammar masteryC1 · An inverted condition with a passive
“you will be asked to leave that day's class.”

From this lesson’s clip, quotation excerpt

Formal should + subject + fail to states a possible failure. A following passive can keep the decision-maker unnamed.

New practice: which sentence keeps an open condition and a passive consequence?

Original teaching activities: Hibiscus Teach. Film and television clips belong to their respective owners.