Present Perfect or Past Simple?

← Grammar catalogue

B1Grammar Focus

Present Perfect or Past Simple?

I can move from an experience connected to now to details in a finished past time.

Created by , British English teacher.

I’m studying:

Try the activities, then check your answers.

Choose a short recording.

Start with the contrast

“I’ve visited a film studio twice.” “Really? When did you go?” “I went last August.” The first sentence counts experiences up to now; the last locates one visit in a finished past period.

Read the situation transcript

“I’ve visited a film studio twice.” “Really? When did you go?” “I went last August.” The first sentence counts experiences up to now; the last locates one visit in a finished past period.

Why does the final sentence use went rather than have gone?

Compare your idea

Last August places the visit in a finished past period.

How it works

Two adults exchanging a plain visitor ticket beside a small model building.
I’ve visited this building before.Picture context: the woman describes a visit at an unspecified time before now. The model identifies the building.

Use the present perfect to connect a past experience with the present viewpoint: I’ve visited a studio twice. The exact finished time is not the focus.

Use the past simple when you place the event in a finished past period: I visited it last August. A natural conversation often begins with experience and then asks for past details.

Experience up to now: have/has + past participle. Finished past detail: past simple.

Reference situation

I’ve visited a studio twice.

This counts experiences up to now.

Contrasting viewpoint

I visited one last August.

This locates one visit in a finished past time.

Hear the examples

I’ve visited a studio twice.

This counts experiences up to now.

I visited one last August.

This locates one visit in a finished past time.

Have you ever met an actor?

This asks about experience up to now.

Who did you meet?

This asks for a past detail.

One mistake worth avoiding

Instead of: I have visited the studio yesterday.

Say: I visited the studio yesterday.

Yesterday is a finished past period, so use the past simple in this ordinary account.

You say

Hear the prompt, answer aloud, then deliberately reveal or hear one possible model. Check it and retry with a changed detail.

Your turn 1

State one experience without a finished date.

Compare a possible model
Reveal the model text

I’ve travelled by night train.

Check yourself: Use a present-perfect experience statement.

Retry with one detail of your own. Other wording is welcome when it meets this check.

Your turn 2

Add one finished-time detail.

Compare a possible model
Reveal the model text

I took a night train last summer.

Check yourself: Move to past simple with the finished period.

Retry with one detail of your own. Other wording is welcome when it meets this check.

Your turn 3

Ask an experience question and a follow-up.

Compare a possible model
Reveal the model text

Have you ever visited a castle? When did you go?

Check yourself: Keep experience and dated detail distinct.

Retry with one detail of your own. Other wording is welcome when it meets this check.

Two adults exchanging a plain visitor ticket beside a small model building.
I visited it last summer.Picture context: she now gives a finished past time for that visit. Use the past simple with last summer.

Two guided self-checks

Say or write your answer before opening a model.

Self-check 1

Complete with a finished date: I ___ the film last Friday. Use see.

Compare a model and explanation

I saw the film last Friday.

Last Friday selects a finished past viewpoint.

Self-check 2

Ask about experience up to now using ever and try.

Compare a model and explanation

Have you ever tried pottery?

Use have plus the participle tried.

Check your understanding

Choose one answer to each question, then check your answers. One of the ten questions is listening.

1. Experience up to now: I ___ that film twice.

2. I ___ the film last Friday.

3. Have you ever ___ a famous building?

4. Which question naturally follows “I’ve been to a film studio”?

5. Choose the sentence with a finished past time.

6. Correct “She has saw the exhibition.”

7. “I’ve never tried skiing.” What period is normally considered here?

8. When did the speaker visit the castle?

Read the listening transcript

I’ve visited that castle once. I went last summer.

Opening this transcript makes this a reading-supported attempt.

9. Choose the correct experience/detail pair.

10. What is the key choice in this lesson?

Automatic scoring needs JavaScript. Use the answer key after attempting all ten questions.

Answer key with explanations

  1. Experience up to now: I ___ that film twice.

    have seen: Have seen counts experiences from a present viewpoint.

  2. I ___ the film last Friday.

    saw: Last Friday is a finished past period.

  3. Have you ever ___ a famous building?

    visited: Have is followed by the past participle visited.

  4. Which question naturally follows “I’ve been to a film studio”?

    When did you go?: A finished visit can be explored with a past-simple detail question.

  5. Choose the sentence with a finished past time.

    I met her in 2022.: In 2022 places the meeting in a finished past period.

  6. Correct “She has saw the exhibition.”

    She has seen the exhibition.: Use the participle seen after has.

  7. “I’ve never tried skiing.” What period is normally considered here?

    The speaker’s life up to now: Never with this present-perfect experience statement reaches up to now.

  8. When did the speaker visit the castle?

    Last summer: The second sentence gives the finished-time detail.

  9. Choose the correct experience/detail pair.

    I’ve tried sailing. I tried it in May.: The correct pair correctly moves from experience to a finished past time.

  10. What is the key choice in this lesson?

    Connection to now or location in a finished past period: The time viewpoint, not the event’s importance, controls the contrast.

Take it with you

I can move from an experience connected to now to details in a finished past time.

Try the companion lesson

Grammar in Context: Have You Ever…?Explore the Grammar catalogue