Rather Than, Instead of and Instead

← Grammar Hub
B2On my own or with a tutor

Rather Than, Instead of and Instead

In this lesson, you can build a replacement with a suitable complement.

Created by , British English teacher.

I’m studying:

Try the activities, then check your answers.

Choose a short recording.

Before you start

Describe replacing a visit with a call.

See one possible response

We called instead of visiting.

You decide how to organise and share a fictional collection of family photographs.

What you will practise
  • Build a replacement with a suitable complement.
  • Link sentences with a recoverable alternative.
  • Compare alternatives clearly and preserve the chosen action.

Try first. For open responses, a model is one valid answer, not an exact-string key. Preserve the intended meaning and register.

Instead of: name the replaced option

Instead of takes a noun phrase or an -ing construction: We sent a link instead of an attachment; we sorted the photos instead of printing them. The complement names the option not used in this account.

We shared a private link instead of a large attachment.

I made a shortlist instead of printing every photograph.

They share a web link on a laptop while an attachment file remains unselected, depicted only by generic interface shapes. No actual readable URL, upload or sent attachment.
We sent a link instead of an attachment.Instead of names the alternative not used in this account.

Instead: let context supply the alternative

Instead can stand without an of-complement when the alternative is already clear: We didn’t print the album. We shared it online instead. Do not add a bare noun straight after instead where instead of is needed.

The album was too large to email, so I sent a link instead.

I didn’t delete the blurred pictures. Instead, I put them in a separate folder.

Rather than: keep the comparison clear

Rather than connects alternatives, often highlighting a choice or contrast. Use clear matching structures: crop rather than delete; cropping rather than deleting. At the start, Rather than delete them, I saved a copy is natural. Some variation is possible; do not turn parallelism into an absolute surface rule.

We decided to organise the pictures by event rather than by person.

Rather than delete the originals, I saved edited copies.

Compare sorting methods on both sides

organise the picturesby eventrather thanby person
Both alternatives describe the method of organising the same pictures. Keep the relation clear without imposing an absolute identical-form rule.
They view their photo album online on a tablet and laptop, with no printed album. A closed unused paper tray may represent the printing alternative, without duplicate pictures or words.
We didn’t print the album. We shared it online instead.The alternative is recovered from the preceding sentence.

Guided practice

Say or write your answer first. Then compare the meaning and grammar with the model.

1. We sent a link ___ a large file. Use instead of.

Compare a model and explanation

We sent a link instead of a large file.

Of introduces the replaced noun phrase.

Accept a grammatical alternative that satisfies the stated prompt and this item’s explanation; the model is not an exhaustive exact-string key.

2. We labelled them instead of delete them.

Compare a model and explanation

We labelled them instead of deleting them.

After instead of, use the -ing construction for this action.

Accept a grammatical alternative that satisfies the stated prompt and this item’s explanation; the model is not an exhaustive exact-string key.

3. We saved copies instead of replacing the originals.

Compare a model and explanation

We didn’t replace the originals. We saved copies instead.

Both versions preserve the chosen and rejected actions.

Accept a grammatical alternative that satisfies the stated prompt and this item’s explanation; the model is not an exhaustive exact-string key.

4. The file was too large. I sent a link instead. What is the link replacing?

Compare a model and explanation

Sending the large file.

The previous sentence supplies the unchosen alternative.

Accept a grammatical alternative that satisfies the stated prompt and this item’s explanation; the model is not an exhaustive exact-string key.

5. We sorted by date rather than location. Make both methods explicit.

Compare a model and explanation

We sorted by date rather than by location.

Repeating by makes the parallel comparison clear, though omission can be natural.

Accept a grammatical alternative that satisfies the stated prompt and this item’s explanation; the model is not an exhaustive exact-string key.

6. I saved the originals rather than deleting them. Begin Rather than delete.

Compare a model and explanation

Rather than delete the originals, I saved them.

The initial bare-verb pattern is natural here.

Accept a grammatical alternative that satisfies the stated prompt and this item’s explanation; the model is not an exhaustive exact-string key.

7. I printed six photos instead of twelve. Does this say I printed eighteen?

Compare a model and explanation

No.

Six was the chosen quantity; twelve was the replaced option.

Accept a grammatical alternative that satisfies the stated prompt and this item’s explanation; the model is not an exhaustive exact-string key.

8. Choose edited copies over changes to originals, and a link over a large attachment.

Compare a model and explanation

We’ll save edited copies rather than change the originals. The attachment is too large, so we’ll send a link instead.

Each alternative remains clear and the future actions are plans, not completed work.

Accept a grammatical alternative that satisfies the stated prompt and this item’s explanation; the model is not an exhaustive exact-string key.

A short conversation

Listen to the exchange, then take one role. The speaker labels identify roles; do not narrate them.

Open the conversation transcript

Relative: Shall we print the whole album?

Photographer: I’d choose twelve pictures rather than print everything.

Relative: And how will everyone see the rest?

Photographer: We can send a private link instead of a large attachment.

Listening checks

Listen to each extract, then choose the best answer. These three questions have their own score.

1. What did the speaker do?
Read the listening transcript

I didn’t delete the blurred pictures. I moved them to a separate folder instead.

2. What was sent?
Read the listening transcript

We sent six edited pictures instead of the full album.

3. What does the account preserve?
Read the listening transcript

Rather than change the originals, we saved edited copies.

Answer key with explanations

  1. What did the speaker do?

    Moved the pictures without deleting them.: Instead identifies the chosen alternative.

    Compare all choices
    • Deleted and moved every original.: Deletion is explicitly denied.
    • Printed all of them.: Printing is not stated.
    • Moved the pictures without deleting them.: Instead identifies the chosen alternative.

  2. What was sent?

    Six edited pictures.: The full album is the replaced option.

    Compare all choices
    • Six edited pictures.: The full album is the replaced option.
    • Nothing at all.: Sending the pictures is asserted.
    • Both six pictures and the full album.: The replacement relation does not state both.

  3. What does the account preserve?

    The originals were not changed in this editing choice.: Saving copies is contrasted with changing the originals.

    Compare all choices
    • Every original was deleted.: That is not the stated alternative.
    • The originals were not changed in this editing choice.: Saving copies is contrasted with changing the originals.
    • No editing of any kind occurred.: Edited copies were saved.

Mastery quiz

Choose the best answer for each situation. The score is out of eight.

1. Which follows instead of naturally in this action contrast?
2. Which sentence uses instead without an of-complement correctly?
3. Which keeps the sorting methods parallel and explicit?
4. In I printed six instead of twelve, how many were printed?
5. Which preserves a decision to save copies rather than alter originals?
6. Is Rather than delete them, I saved them a possible structure?
7. What must be clear when instead has no following complement?
8. Which account avoids inventing a completed action?
Answer key with explanations

  1. Which follows instead of naturally in this action contrast?

    printing every picture: The preposition takes an -ing construction here.

    Compare all choices
    • print every picture: The bare verb does not fit this target pattern.
    • printing every picture: The preposition takes an -ing construction here.
    • to print every picture: The to-infinitive does not fit after of here.

  2. Which sentence uses instead without an of-complement correctly?

    The file was too large, so I sent a link instead.: The earlier clause makes the alternative recoverable.

    Compare all choices
    • I sent a link instead the file.: A following noun phrase needs instead of in this pattern.
    • I sent instead a file a link of.: The alternative is not coherently structured.
    • The file was too large, so I sent a link instead.: The earlier clause makes the alternative recoverable.

  3. Which keeps the sorting methods parallel and explicit?

    by date rather than by person: Both phrases state the sorting basis.

    Compare all choices
    • by date rather than by person: Both phrases state the sorting basis.
    • by date rather than to person: To person does not express the matching method.
    • by date rather than person was: The second structure is incomplete.

  4. In I printed six instead of twelve, how many were printed?

    Six.: Twelve is the replaced quantity.

    Compare all choices
    • Eighteen.: The quantities are not added.
    • Six.: Twelve is the replaced quantity.
    • Twelve.: That is the unchosen option.

  5. Which preserves a decision to save copies rather than alter originals?

    We saved copies instead of altering the originals.: The chosen action and rejected alternative remain.

    Compare all choices
    • We altered the originals instead of saving copies.: This reverses the choice.
    • We saved no copies and altered nothing.: That denies the stated action.
    • We saved copies instead of altering the originals.: The chosen action and rejected alternative remain.

  6. Is Rather than delete them, I saved them a possible structure?

    Yes.: An initial rather than phrase can use the base verb in this pattern.

    Compare all choices
    • Yes.: An initial rather than phrase can use the base verb in this pattern.
    • No, delete must be past after rather than.: The base form is natural in this construction.
    • No, every than must be followed by a comparative adjective.: Rather than has other established uses.

  7. What must be clear when instead has no following complement?

    Which earlier alternative is being replaced.: Context supplies the omitted option.

    Compare all choices
    • The speaker’s exact age.: Age is not required for this reference.
    • Which earlier alternative is being replaced.: Context supplies the omitted option.
    • That both alternatives happened.: Replacement generally contrasts the selected action with an unselected one here.

  8. Which account avoids inventing a completed action?

    We plan to share a link instead of emailing the album.: It reports a plan, not completion.

    Compare all choices
    • The album was emailed because we will not email it.: This does not preserve the intended future choice.
    • We already shared it, although we have only planned it.: The claims conflict.
    • We plan to share a link instead of emailing the album.: It reports a plan, not completion.

Use it in your own words

One choice, two structures

Describe a real or fictional choice with instead of, then as two sentences with instead.

Reveal a possible response

I used a notebook instead of an app. I didn’t use an app. I used a notebook instead.

  • Preserve the same chosen option
  • Keep the alternative recoverable

Other familiar tools or methods are welcome.

Explain the contrast

Compare two ways of organising information using rather than. Explain a reason without claiming the other method is always wrong.

Reveal a possible response

I organise recipes by meal rather than by ingredient because that suits how I plan dinner. The other method could work for someone else.

  • Make parallel alternatives
  • Tie the choice to a purpose

Other non-sensitive information is acceptable.

Put it all together

Plan a small family recipe collection. Choose how to organise it, what to leave out and how to share it. Retrieve a useful exception or condition from this level.

Reveal a possible response

We’ll organise recipes by meal rather than by contributor. We’ll include short notes instead of long stories. If necessary, we can add a separate notes page. The file may be large, so we’ll share a link instead, except when someone asks for a printed copy.

  • Keep three alternatives clear
  • Retrieve a meaningful condition or exception
  • Transfer beyond photographs

Other coherent choices are acceptable; this is a fictional publishing plan.

Take it with you

Rather than compares alternatives; instead of introduces a replacement phrase, and instead can link a replacement statement. Keep complements and parallel structure appropriate to the construction.